Caribbean Business Review · Season 4, Episode 8
CCJ Under Scrutiny
Can Trust Be Rebuilt?
Marlene Malahoo Forte, KC, MP · Former Attorney General of Jamaica and former Minister of Legal and Constitutional Affairs
Broadcast:
Episode Overview
Marlene Malahoo Forte, KC, MP, joins Joseph Cox to examine the controversy surrounding leaked internal discussions at the Caribbean Court of Justice, allegations of panel fixing and the implications for judicial independence and public confidence. The conversation also considers Jamaica’s constitutional choices and the CCJ’s role in Caribbean integration.
Malahoo Forte argues that leaking confidential judicial discussions was deeply damaging. While disagreement exists within institutions, she maintains that judges should resolve differences privately and professionally. Her criticism of the leak is distinct from her assessment of the underlying allegations: in her view, the matters raised do not prove panel fixing, but they do require explanation.
The discussion distinguishes the independence of an individual judge from the independence of the judicial branch as a whole. Malahoo Forte emphasises freedom from improper influence and the importance of public confidence. Joseph questions whether changing panel composition so that all judges sit on all panels is sufficient to restore trust. She considers the administrative rationale, while arguing that the change alone does not settle the allegations or replace a fuller explanation of panel assignment.
The conversation then turns to Jamaica’s choices between retaining the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council, adopting the CCJ as its final court or establishing a final Jamaican court. Malahoo Forte outlines the political and constitutional complexity of reform, including the need for broad agreement and a referendum in Jamaica’s move to a republic. She favours an incremental approach and acknowledges continuing public divisions over the final court.
Her practical priority is strengthening lower and intermediate courts. Timely hearings and improved access to justice, she argues, matter directly to ordinary people and should not be overshadowed by debate about the apex court.
As a committed regionalist, Malahoo Forte also stresses the CCJ’s original jurisdiction in interpreting the Revised Treaty of Chaguaramas. That function connects the court to the Caribbean Single Market, regional business and economic development, beyond its appellate role. CBR’s synthesis centres on the need for clear public explanations, institutional accountability and renewed trust while the work of constitutional reform and Caribbean integration continues.
CBR strategic takeaways
- Judicial independence, confidential deliberations and public confidence
- Panel assignment changes and allegations requiring explanation
- Jamaica’s constitutional reform and final-court choices
- Lower and intermediate courts, timely hearings and access to justice
- The CCJ’s original jurisdiction and Caribbean economic integration
Episode artwork

Related CBR research
- CBR Intelligence Note Vol. 1 No. 17: The Architecture of Judicial Confidence
- Explore the CBR Intelligence research catalogue
